Launched in 2022: our graded card site at!

We launched a graded card site with hundreds of our shop favorites, including non-sports cards like Star Wars and Pokemon. We offer a variety of years and sports graded by PSA, Beckett, the new CardScore system, and others as Jon has broadened his collecting to include sports stars from even the current decade. As a courtesy to our regulars who visit our shop in Shelbyville, we will hold all new cards for 30 days before adding to the new site.

In-store, half the shop is dedicated to baseball, football, basketball, and hockey trading cards, including full-year sets and unopened wax boxes from a variety of years, including some current years! We offer 28 feet of counter space with seats and phone charging stations where you can search our huge $5 boxes: more than a hundred thousand ungraded cards sorted by year for the thrill of the hunt. Within our glass cases, find graded and ungraded rare cards. Looking for something specific? Call to find out if we have it in stock.

We are always buying; please call first to make sure Jon will be available on the day you'd like to bring in your cards for evaluation or to set up an appointment. You can also call,. email, or direct message through the socials and tell us what types of cards you have, their age and condition, and which you think are most valuable. We may also request photos, but please don't send photos until requested. While we focus on vintage cards prior to 1989, we are happy to consider other collections. If you are looking on eBay for comparable prices, remember that listing prices are what the seller hopes to make and do not necessarily represent sold prices.

We aren't yet able to offer new wax boxes direct from the manufacturers, but please stay tuned! Keith in the shop sometimes is able to acquire one or two new wax boxes that he will list for sale as available.

What are you waiting for? Hop over to right now!